AI DraftFeb 26, 2026
Academy Manufactor + Camellia, the Seedmiser + Jaheira, Friend of the Forest + Peregrin Took
Overview
Academy Manufactor and Peregrin Took are both replacement effects that modify token creation; their interaction is resolved by choosing an order for replacement effects as described in . Jaheira’s static effect simply grants all tokens you control “
: Add 
.” Camellia triggers when you sacrifice one or more Foods and can be paid for or triggered after tokens exist; you can’t sacrifice a single Food to pay multiple costs per Ruling [2024-11-08]. Also, Peregrin’s replacement only applies if you are the one creating the tokens (Ruling [2023-06-16]).
: Add .” Camellia triggers when you sacrifice one or more Foods and can be paid for or triggered after tokens exist; you can’t sacrifice a single Food to pay multiple costs per Ruling [2024-11-08]. Also, Peregrin’s replacement only applies if you are the one creating the tokens (Ruling [2023-06-16]).Step 1
Identify the token-creation event and the affected player (the player who would get the token(s)). The affected player chooses which replacement effect to apply first per .
Step 2
If the affected player chooses Academy Manufactor first: the original 'would create one Clue/Food/Treasure' event is replaced so that you create one of each (Clue + Food + Treasure). After that replacement resolves, check for other replacement effects; Peregrin’s replacement is still applicable (because one or more tokens would be created under your control), so apply Peregrin to add an additional Food, yielding Clue + Treasure + Food ×2.
Step 3
If the affected player chooses Peregrin first: Peregrin replaces the original 'would create one token' event by making the event create that token plus an additional Food (so a single Food becomes two Food tokens). Then Academy Manufactor can apply to those Food-creation portions: Manufactor replaces each Food creation, producing one Clue + one Food + one Treasure for each Food that would be created. With two Food events that becomes 2 × (Clue + Food + Treasure) = two Clues, two Foods, two Treasures (six tokens).
Step 4
All tokens created in either ordering receive Jaheira’s token-granting ability because Jaheira’s static effect grants tokens you control ": Add ."
: Add ."Step 5
When you later sacrifice Foods (for Camellia’s Forage or Peregrin’s activated ability ‘Sacrifice three Foods: Draw a card.’), Camellia’s triggered ability looks for the sacrifice event textually on its trigger; if you sacrifice one or more Foods in the same event, Camellia’s ability triggers once (its trigger reads “Whenever you sacrifice one or more Foods, create a 1/1 green Squirrel creature token”). Sacrificing a single Food can’t be used to pay more than one cost at once per Ruling [2024-11-08].
Resolution
If the same player controls Academy Manufactor, Peregrin Took, and Jaheira (and is the one creating the tokens), that player chooses the order to apply the replacement effects under . If they apply Academy Manufactor first, a single would-be Food/Clue/Treasure creation becomes one Clue + one Food + one Treasure, and then Peregrin can add one more Food to make Clue + Treasure + Food ×2 (four tokens total). If they apply Peregrin first to a single Food creation, Peregrin makes it two Food tokens, and then Academy Manufactor replaces each Food creation, producing two sets (2 × (Clue + Food + Treasure) = 6 tokens). All tokens created will have Jaheira’s “: Add ” ability. Camellia’s triggered ability triggers when you actually sacrifice one or more Foods; sacrifices used as costs must obey Ruling [2024-11-08]. Peregrin’s replacement only applies when you are the one creating the tokens (Ruling [2023-06-16]).
: Add ” ability. Camellia’s triggered ability triggers when you actually sacrifice one or more Foods; sacrifices used as costs must obey Ruling [2024-11-08]. Peregrin’s replacement only applies when you are the one creating the tokens (Ruling [2023-06-16]).Feedback